So the sock on Braden's hand did not keep him from sucking his thumb. We taped the sock to his shirt sleeve so that he couldn't get it off of his hand, and we would find him in his bed in the morning with his shirt off and his thumb in his mouth.
I talked to my friend Emily about it, and she told me about her friend who taught her 18-month-old baby how to take a binky. With my stubborn boy, I thought there was no way this could happen for me.
With low hopes, I started keeping a binky in his bed and one in the car, which were the two places he seemed to suck his thumb the most. For about a week now, I've been sitting with him as he goes to sleep at night and for naps, and I won't let him suck his thumb, but I let him suck on a binky. And in the car when he sucks his thumb, I hand him a binky to put in his mouth.
I looked in my rearview mirror and saw this today:
He is not completely off the thumb - I still catch him sucking it sometimes. But I think we are making progress. Giving him an alternative instead of making him stop sucking altogether has been working better for me and for him. He's not fighting me all of the time like he started to with the sock.
I am hopeful that he won't turn into his almost 6-year-old thumbsucking sister. We are working with her too. She really wants to stop. So soon we may be a thumbsucker-free household.



